When I was a teenager, I was a writer for one of Canada’s bestselling children’s magazines. Among other things, I was the resident Harry Potter expert. When a new Potter book or movie was coming out, I was the guy the editors called to fete the release.

By the time the curtain closed on Deathly Hallows Part 2, I’d become especially adept at seamlessly integrating references from the Wizarding World into my cover stories. Perhaps that is why lately I can’t seem to rid my mind of a particularly gruesome observation: Donald Trump is the Dolores Umbridge of our times.

As it turns out, I’m not the first person to see the similarities. In fact, the term “Trumpbridge” trended online in early 2016 when then-candidate Trump was merely threatening to dismantle the U.S. Department of Education. (On March 20, 2025, he signed an executive order to make good on that promise.)

The meme proved to be prophetic. Umbridge is not only one of the “Most Hated Movie Characters of All Time,” but readers will also remember her attempts to suppress the truth of Lord Voldemort’s return on the Ministry of Magic’s behalf by rewriting the Hogwarts curriculum, firing school faculty, arresting political dissidents, and punishing those who dared to challenge her.

In a memorable scene from Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix, Professor Umbridge supervises Harry in detention, where he is forced to write “I must not tell lies” until the message “sinks in”—literally. Image: Warner Bros.

If this sounds all too familiar, that’s because it is. Consider this:

Revisionist history

Since returning to the Oval Office in early 2025, Trump has attempted to rewrite history by pardoning thousands of insurrectionists who stormed Congress on January 6, 2021 in a violent bid to overturn the 2020 presidential election results, incredibly calling them “hostages” and “patriots.” He has also ordered the Smithsonian Institution and National Park Service to remove exhibits and other educational materials related to slavery that, according to him, “inappropriately disparage Americans.”

No press pass for you

He has repeatedly banned media outlets from the White House, including when they refused to play along with his absurd decision to rename the Gulf of Mexico and, again, when they published stories about him he did not like.

‘Trumped up’ charges

His Department of Justice has launched criminal investigations into a long list of rivals who have openly criticized him, including several prominent Democratic U.S. Senators and House Representatives. As the non-profit group Protect Democracy argues, there are strong, objective indicators that many of the investigations are politically motivated.

The Hate U Give

The 47th U.S. President could also lay claim to that title of “Most Hated Movie Character.” After all, he has a penchant for dubious rankings, the film credits to qualify, and the public enmity to back it up. Indeed, Trump had not only the lowest average approval rating during his first term of any president since 1945, when modern polling began, but the average approval rating of his second term has so far sunk even lower, and he had the lowest approval rating of any president leading into this month’s Congressional mid-term elections.

As if those parallels with Hogwarts High Inquisitor were not obvious enough, Trump’s continued attacks on higher education have proven to be a bit too on-the-nose—even for the Dark Lord, who famously does not have one.

Most notably, the Commander-in-Chief has been locked in an escalating war with Harvard University for control over who the school admits, who it hires, what subjects it teaches, and how it disciplines students.

How we got here

The dispute started with what seemed like a noble goal: combating antisemitism. University campuses around the world became a locus of anti-war protests following Hamas’ October 7, 2023 attacks against Israel and the latter’s subsequent invasion of Gaza. With tensions rising between pro-Israel and pro-Palestine demonstrators, some American college students occupied school buildings and set up encampments in common spaces. By September 2024, the social cohesion between Jewish and non-Jewish students and faculty had deteriorated significantly.

Americans re-elected Trump later that Fall and, within two weeks of returning to the White House, he established the “Joint Task Force to Combat Anti-Semitism,” a working group of federal departments that would seek to eliminate antisemitic harassment across college campuses.

New York’s Columbia University was the first to feel its sting. Rather than investigate and sue the University to enforce Title VI of the 1964 Civil Rights Act, which would have required Trump’s administration to prove the school discriminated against students, the Joint Task Force simply announced that it had frozen over $400 million in federal grants and contracts as a penalty for the school’s “failure to protect Jewish students and staff.” If Columbia wanted the funds to start flowing again—money it needed in part for important medical and social research—it would have to comply with a set of demands, which included suspending or expelling students who were involved in anti-war encampments. Columbia decided it was better to cut a deal than to cut its wrists; the school acceded to most of the Joint Task Force’s demands and stopped the bleeding.

But the spat with Columbia was just target practice for what was to come.

Donald Trump
Commander-in-(Mis)Chief: U.S. President Donald Trump. Image: Brian Snyder/Reuters.

Poison Ivy

Next up was Harvard, a school that—if you squint hard enough—bears a striking resemblance to the inimitable Hogwarts. And like that other Big H, Harvard was about to become the site of a major battle, except this one would be fought with words rather than wands.

On April 11, 2025, the Trump administration sent Harvard a demand letter. It may as well have been a Howler. It accused Harvard, like Columbia, of violating federal civil rights laws and perpetuating antisemitism on campus. Unlike Columbia, however, Harvard would need to meet a much longer series of demands to keep $9 billion in federal monies flowing to the institution. They included:

  • “reducing the power held by students”;
  • “reducing the power held by faculty…and administrators more committed to activism than scholarship”;
  • ending affirmative action and implementing “merit-based” admissions and hiring policies by “ceas[ing] all preferences based on race, color, religion, sex, or national origin”;
  • sharing all admissions, hiring, and “related data” with the federal government for audit;
  • “International Admissions Reform” to “prevent admitting students hostile to the American values and institutions”—whatever that means;
  • implementing “Viewpoint Diversity in Admissions and Hiring” at a departmental and teaching unit level;
  • “Reforming Programs with Egregious Records of Antisemitism or Other Bias”, including the Harvard Law School International Human Rights Clinic;
  • ending all diversity, equity, and inclusion programs;
  • centralizing student discipline in a body accountable to the university president;
  • ending support for and recognition of specific student clubs, including “Law Students 4 Palestine” (à la Educational Decree Number Twenty-Four); and
  • establishing a process to encourage “whistleblowers” to report the university’s noncompliance with federal laws to the Joint Task Force and to protect them when they do.

While any one of these conditions could have been taken straight out of Umbridge’s authoritarian playbook, that last one is reminiscent of her Inquisitorial Squad, a band of goons assembled to do the Ministry’s bidding. The message is clear: “At Trump’s Harvard, snitches won’t get stitches; they’ll get extra credit!”

While Columbia rolled over, Harvard fought back. The school rejected Trump’s demands and “within hours” the administration had blocked $2.2 billion in federal funding. In case the country’s oldest college didn’t take Trump seriously the first time, his Homeland Security secretary also threatened to revoke Harvard’s permission to enroll international students if it didn’t turn over detailed records about its student visa holders, including their coursework. But rather than break Harvard’s resolve, the escalation steeled it.

“Without its international students, Harvard is not Harvard,” a statement posted on Harvard’s social media accounts read at the time. I can personally attest to that. So global is Harvard’s outlook that studying there often felt like preparation for a future diplomatic mission. It is a place where cultures, ideas, and dreams converge, at least when they aren’t being actively stifled.

At this, there was no turning back. Trump had jumped through the trapdoor. He was about to encounter the Ivy League’s answer to Devil’s Snare. On April 21, 2025, the University sued the U.S. government, alleging an illegal “pressure campaign” by Trump designed to wrest control over its academic freedoms under the guise of combating antisemitism. The following month, Homeland Security terminated Harvard’s participation in the Student Exchange Visa Program and ordered more than 6,700 current students to transfer schools or face removal from the country. The next day, Harvard won a temporary restraining order against the government’s actions and filed a new suit to permanently enjoin the feds from blocking international enrollments.

Commander-in-(Mis)chief

By September 2025, the U.S. District Court of Massachusetts had granted Harvard’s motion for summary judgment. The Court agreed with the university that the Trump administration’s attempts to meddle in academics, admissions, and hiring were arbitrary and violated the school’s protected conduct under the First Amendment to the Constitution, including its freedom of speech. In the presiding judge’s own words:

Free speech has always been a hallmark of our democracy. The Supreme Court itself has recognized that efforts to educate people, change minds, and foster tolerance all benefit from more open communication, not less. As Justice Brandeis wrote in the seminal case of Whitney v. California, “[i]f there be time to expose through discussion the falsehood and fallacies, to avert the evil by the processes of education, the remedy to be applied is more speech, not enforced silence,”1 or, in this case, the forced adoption
of a political orthodoxy. As pertains to this case, it is important to recognize and remember that if speech can be curtailed in the name of the Jewish people today, then just as easily the speech of the Jews (and anyone else) can be curtailed when the political winds change direction.

Never one to admit defeat, Trump appealed that decision. Then, in one of his notorious late-night Truth Social tirades, the president said he would not agree to settle his allegations against Harvard unless it agreed to pay $1 billion in cash to the federal treasury as part of any deal. School officials collectively shrugged and declined to comment.

Langdell Hall at Harvard Law School. The Latin inscription on the building reads: Non sub homine sed sub deo et lege, meaning “Not under man but under God and law.” Image: Agathon Fric.

Lessons from the frontline

The Battle of Harvard illustrates several lessons about democracy and the rule of law.

First, it isn’t over ’til the fat lady sings. No, I do not refer to the one whose portrait guards the Gryffindor common room. I’m referring to Lady Justice. So long as Trump has an avenue for appeal, this fight continues. Although the U.S. District Court initially ruled in Harvard’s favour on the grant money and international enrollment cases, the federal government appealed those decisions. Oral argument proceeded over two days last month, and the decisions of the First Circuit Court of Appeals remain pending. It is possible we won’t have a definitive answer to whether the executive may lawfully use federal money as collateral to extract concessions on academic policy until the Supreme Court weighs in, as it did in the similarly charged 2023 case of Students for Fair Admissions v Harvard. In that case, the majority overturned decades of precedent that, until then, had condoned the use of race in college admissions. (The government had separately sued Harvard, unsuccessfully, for allegedly failing to comply with that judgment.) It’s anyone’s guess what the current Court would do in this case, given its 6-3 conservative majority. Time will tell.

Second, this fight was never really about antisemitism per se. It was always about academic independence and ordered liberty. For instance, it is telling that the government minimized the spectre of antisemitism on appeal, focusing instead on a jurisdictional argument in a bid to reverse the decision. Moreover, the university never denied that creating a safe campus environment for all members of its community was a worthy objective. In fact, Harvard had already initiated its own process to address antisemitism on campus a full year before Trump returned to the White House. What Harvard opposed was Trump’s unconstitutional attempt to extort the university in order to make its ideology align with his own. (It’s too bad he’s focused on the wrong type of alignment.) Certainly, it is not unreasonable to expect that private institutions should contribute to public policy goals and promote the general welfare if they are to receive public subsidies. That is what Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 is designed to do. At the same time, such public–private bargains should be fundamentally transparent, predictable, and rooted in law, not subject to the whims and caprice of a very pink handmaiden or—hem hem—a very orange bully.

Third, the president’s attacks on Harvard were never really about Harvard. Instead, they were about creating a wave of intimidation and fear at postsecondary schools across the U.S. to secure policy compliance. The Homeland Security secretary didn’t even try to hide the fact that she wanted to make an example out of (Un)Fair Harvard. As her decertification letter stated, “Consequences must follow to send a clear signal to…all universities that want to enjoy the privilege of enrolling foreign students, that the Trump Administration will enforce the law and root out the evils of anti-Americanism and antisemitism in society and campuses.” In other words, Harvard was an easy target. It’s hard to feel bad for an elite institution that most Americans will never set foot in and that some would argue should not receive as much public money as it currently does. Plus, if the richest private school in the country with the most to lose couldn’t knock out this troll, then perhaps every other school would just fall into line.

Which is why, fourth, you cannot count on someone else to vindicate your rights. If Harvard had simply followed Columbia’s lead, as so many other universities have done, students might have wound up traversing the Old Yard under silk banners bearing Trump’s mug. The Primal Scream might have been phased out and the “old punishments” re-instituted. By the same token, Harvard’s leadership demonstrates that it is never too late to stand up for what is right.

But, fifth, do not kid yourself: fighting for what’s right is expensive, both financially and spiritually. For example, in an appearance last month at a Jewish student event, Harvard President Alan Garber admitted that the amount the university spent on legal fees last year skyrocketed to an eye-watering $126 million, well above the $20 million it historically spent in an average year. And, as the dispute rages on, some damage has already been done. Case in point: international student enrollments across the U.S. continue to drop and some donors are sending their cheques elsewhere. Like the high-flying sport of Quidditch, standing up for your principles is not for the faint of heart.

Lastly, unlike Dumbledore’s Army, which operated in secret, Democracy‘s Army works in plain sight. It relies on courageous muggles and moxie, not magic—on ballots and legal briefs, not fantastic beasts—to make progress.

And, above all, it does not yield until the mischief is managed.

  1. 274 U.S. 357, 377 (1927) (Brandeis, J., concurring). ↩︎

Discover more from Agathon Fric

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Agathon Fric

Agathon Fric is a lawyer and writer based in Calgary. He received his Master of Laws from Harvard Law School, where he was a Dean’s Scholar.

Leave a Reply